Melt-in-Your-Mouth Butter Mints Recipe

I don’t know about y’all, but growing up in the South we had three essential things on the menu when we went to a wedding reception or a bridal tea: punch, peanuts and pastel butter mints.

It didn’t matter what else you had to eat, those three things were DEFINITELY gonna make an appearance on the table.

Those pastel butter mints have kinda fallen out of favor over the years and they are increasingly hard to find in the stores.  I’m here today to show you how you can make these AT HOME and they taste 1,000% better than the stale store-bought kind! I promise.

Since it’s Christmastime, I decided to spice things up a bit and go with four different flavors of candy- peppermint, cinnamon, spearmint and caramel.

Yes, I said caramel!  I did NOT use essential oils for that one (since unfortunately we don’t have a caramel essential oil but WOW could you imagine if we did!?!?!) So, instead I used a few drops of Watkins caramel extract that I found at Walmart.

Here’s a quick video if you like watching these kinda things….

Or you can just get the regular ol’ recipe here:

Melt-in-Your-Mouth Butter Mints
Prep time
Total time
Sweet butter mints just like the pastel ones you used to love at the Baptist wedding receptions.
Recipe type: party
Serves: 3-4 cups
  • 1 stick Butter, softened
  • 3.5 cups Powdered Sugar
  • 2 T. Milk
  • Young Living Vitality essential oil* (I used peppermint, cinnamon & spearmint)
  • Watkins Caramel Extract (optional)
  • Red and green food coloring (or colors of choice)
  • *You can substitute with a few drops of your favorite extract or flavoring
  1. Whisk together softened butter with powdered sugar, 1 cup at a time, until full incorporated.
  2. Add milk, 1 tablespoon at a time, until it forms a nice soft dough ball that you can easily form with your hands.
  3. Divide dough into 4 equal sections
  4. Add 1-2 drops essential oil along with 1-2 drops of food coloring to each section
  5. Roll and squeeze the dough thoroughly to incorporate the flavoring and evenly distribute colors, or leave it mottled for the "peppermint" color
  6. Roll out into a "snake" and cut into ½" pieces to resemble a butter mint.

Get all the great DIY handmade gifts here:These make perfect stocking stuffers or little gifts for coworkers, neighbors or teachers. Enjoy!!

Today is also the 4th Annual Handmade Holiday Blog Hop and facebook party! For the past FOUR (whoa!) years, my blog buddies and I have hosted an online facebook party where you can win prizes and learn how to make handmade gifts with essential oils.The party is tonight, showcasing all these amazing handmade gift ideas and giving away lots of goodies. We hope you will join us and tell your friends.

RSVP here and attend from the comfort of your couch! You can get a preview of tonight’s party ideas on my friend’s blogs:

Scented Gift Tag Printables by One Project Closer

Mulling Spices by Shaken Together

Melt-in-your-Mouth Butter Mints by Unskinny Boppy

Scented Sachet Ornaments by Here Comes the Sun

Gemstone Infused Roll-on by DIY Showoff

Infinity Diffuser Bracelet by Practically Functional

Leather Tassel Keychain Diffuser by Making Lemonade

Easy DIY Holiday Candles by Eat Sleep Be

« »

Speak Your Mind


Rate this recipe:  


  1. Beth
    You are so right! Mints used to be a staple at any formal affair. Recently here in TN, homemade Butter Mints are making a comeback. Glad I saved my molds!
    Merry Christmas!

  2. May I simply just say what a relief to uncove someone that truly
    knows what they’re talking about on the net.
    Youu actually understand how to bring a problem to light and make it important.

    A lot more people really need to read this and understand this side of the story.
    It’s surprising youu are not more popular because you certainly possess the gift.


« »